
"Because I'm good enough, I'm smart enough, and, doggonit, people like me!"
~Stuart Smalley
When I reflect on McCarthy, for some reason the SNL skit with Al Franken a.k.a. Stuart Smalley and Michael Jordan comes to mind. Obviously, Jordan needed a confident boost in the skit and Stuart was there to help. Maybe Brandon needs Stuart to cheer him up at this point in his baseball career.
***Let's jump into the time machine back to post-2006 season***
What was the front office thinking when they traded John Danks and Nick Masset to the White Sox for Brandon McCarthy?
This was the question I was trying to answer today when reflecting on McCarthy's Ranger career. If you look at his White Sox numbers you began to understand why the Rangers had a love interest in this guy. But you have to wonder if they (front office) ever looked at his frame and wondered if he was fragile. Even with the "extra weight" back in the future (2009), McCarthy looks like a flag should be at the top of his head.
Here is a look at his White Sox numbers:
2005: 3-2, 4.03 E.R.A., 10 starts, 67 IP, 1.179 WHIP, 6.4 K/9
2006: 4-7, 4.68 E.R.A., 2 starts, 84.2 IP, 1.299 WHIP, 7.3 K/9
Total: 7-9, 4.39 E.R.A., 12 starts, 151.2 IP, 1.246 WHIP, 6.9 K/9
These numbers are respectable to say the least, especially his WHIP both years. His E.R.A. is comparable to Padilla's career E.R.A. (4.36) and Padilla hasn't had an earned run average that low since 2003 before his time with the Rangers. Now let's hop back into the time machine and go back to '09.
***Present Day***
How did he get another shoulder injury? Did he sleep akwardly one night a couple of weeks ago? Did he bump a door frame? These are the questions that plague frustrated Rangers fans.
Here are McCarthy's Rangers stats:
2007: 5-10, 4.87 E.R.A., 22 starts, 101.2 IP, 1.564 WHIP, 5.2 K/9
2008: 1-1, 4.09 E.R.A., 5 starts, 22 IP, 1.273 WHIP, 4.1 K/9
2009: 5-2, 4.92 E.R.A., 11 starts, 64 IP, 1.438 WHIP, 6.2 K/9
Total: 11-13, 4.80 E.R.A., 38 starts, 187.2 IP, 1.487 WHIP, 5.4 K/9
Across the board his numbers are worse in Texas than in Chicago. In Chicago he had 7 victories in 12 starts while in Texas he has 11 wins in 38 starts. How does someone explain this annomoly? Does Chicago have a better pitching program? Does he just have bad luck in Texas?
What does Texas do with McCarthy from here? How can you feel confident that he will ever give you 200 innings in a single season? He is only 25 years old, but don't you have to look at his history and throw your hands up?
The Rangers will probably have another month of shaking their head wondering where it went wrong with Brandon.
What are your feelings on Brandon McCarthy?